Barnes. And the next son of a bitch I catch coppin Z in the bush, Im personally going to take an interest in seein suffer. Tension is derived from the sense that everything the platoon attempts to do appears ineffective against the elusive and ever encroaching enemy. People like Elias get wasted and people like Barnes just go on making up rules any way they want and what do we do, we just sit around in the middle and suck on it! In the closing minutes of Platoon, the character re-emerges with a big smile on his face, and tells Taylor that they'll both be sent homeas "two-timers." You got no proof man. But a cold and ruthless product of warfare. Understanding how networked the entire area has become and how hidden and well stocked the Viet Cong are serve as forewarnings that support the consequence. When the platoon does see action on the all night ambush, Chris and Gardner are obviously insufficiently prepared for combat, which results in Gardner being killed, Tex losing his arm, and Chris getting shot. Throughout the film, we see how Chris is thematically focused on the events he experiences and sees, and is able to pull out the really relevant and meaningful parts which gives him wisdom beyond his years. RHAH: (puffing on his bowl) How do you know the dinks didnt get him. Its all a blur. In the heat of hand to hand combat, Sgt. Thats a good Gook, good and dead. Entdecke Platoon (DVD, 2009, Special Edition Single Disc Version) in groer Auswahl Vergleichen Angebote und Preise Online kaufen bei eBay Kostenlose Lieferung fr viele Artikel! As the platoon departs on helicopters, Taylor witnesses the North Vietnamese Army (NVA) gun down Dafoe's character; a moment which ultimately fuels the final act conflict. Elias tells Barnes that they don't know anything, and they are probably going to run into something. He grins, finding their reactions funny. Oh, you wanna kick ass. (Stone, p. 3) The inference, of course, is that war is such hell that soldiers would do anything to escape it, including causing themselves grave injuries, but inPlatoon, Stone doesn't paint a flatteringpicture of Black soldiers, and he's been called out for it over the years. The platoon gets caught in an enemy ambush, and the Viet Cong causes the platoon to suffer serious casualties. Barnes leads his troops by taking on and acting the tough, hard, insensitive persona he feels is necessary to get his men to respond to him, and to the activities of war in a way that will allow them to actually win. Throughout the film there are indicators that the U.S. troops are not progressing towards victoryvisually expressed in the loss of lives and in the mounting frustration and stress within the platoon. S.SGT Barnes or Sgt. Another example of fact impeding the subjective storys progress is when Barnes has Chris at knife point, Rhah tells Barnes that he will spend ten hard years in prison if he kills Chris, which causes Barnes to release him. Live up to what Grandpa did in the First War and Dad the Second. Another example is when he explains to the men in the head that he killed Elias because he couldnt and wouldnt tolerate a man that doesnt follow orders, he is warning them to follow orders or they will suffer the same fate as Elias did. I figured why should just the poor kids go off to war and the rich kids always get away with it.". ): Course Mom and Dad didnt want me to come, they wanted me to be just like themrespectable, hard-working, making $200 a week, a little house, a family. By the final act, director Oliver Stone provides a piercingcommentary about the lasting effects of war and the consequences ofspontaneous decisions. Gunfire all around, incoming and outgoing, makes them yell to each other. Chris finally obtains a strong aptitude for the war. Barnes would have been court-martialled, the civil war in the platoon would have subsided, and Barnes wouldnt have been able to ultimately kill Elias. Elias. For far too long, they engage in a losing war, deluding themselves that victory is certain. Barnes orders the rest of the platoon to retreat and goes back into the jungle to find Elias's group. After Ibarra saves his life from a vicious crocodile, Elas swears to protect the young man from his enemies, which are legion. Forums. While the platoon is extracting via helicopter, they glimpse Elias, mortally wounded, emerging from the treeline and being chased by a group of North Vietnamese soldiers, who kill him. ELIAS: we been kicking other peoples asses so long I guess its time we got our own kicked. What many might not know is that the pose wasnt planned out beforehand. When you know you know. His letters are composed of very introspective reflections of the events he is experiencing in the war. He is one of the four dead bodies under ponchos. The first casualty of war is innocence. CHRIS: Didnt make much sense. Did he try to kill himself? He later died in an airplane accident. I guess having always been sheltered and special, I just want to be anonymous. Barnes decision to send Chris on the all night ambush has severe ramifications for the new soldier, who is inexperienced in combat, and is blamed for the loss of two men in the platoon. CHRIS: Proofs in his eyes. By doing so, Barnes is able to call their bluff, and deal with this conflict directly and on his terms. When the platoon takes some gruesome losses, an enraged Barnes kills some Vietnamese and orders the burning of their village, outraging the temporarily absent Elias. Six of you boys against me. He volunteers for the war because he wants to experience his own life, not just observe it like other middle-class college boys (Denby 86). End with a murder the last of too bloody many . Bunny and Junior share a pithole as he savagely shoots oncoming NVA soldiers with his rifle but is soon outnumbered and shot to death when an NVA soldier shoots him down and finishes him off with a shot to his mouth as Junior retreats. I saw his eyes when he came back in Elas Character Analysis. When the staff sergeant threatens to kill another person,an enraged Elias physically attacks him. The realm of conflict between Chris and Sergeant Barnes is in their fixed attitudes. From there, the narration becomes more complex and gives a deeper meaning to Platoon: "There are times since, I've felt like the child born of those two fathers. BARNES: Yall take a good look at this lump of shit! 1. Morehouse and Sal are short, Fu Shengs going on an RnR, you dont want to send their asses out on an ambush. ELIAS: Sir, I saw it happen in 66 at Ia Drang. Barnes has engaged in. Huh. Wasnt learning anything (hesitate) And why should just the poor kids go to the war - and the college kids get away with it. How many days you short? One of his hunches is responsible for bringing him to Vietnam, where he develops a theory about finding what he can be proud of: None of this sits well with Sgt. Why did Elias smile at Barnes? Barnes is running the platoon. For example: Barnes doesnt seem to give much thought to sending the new, inexperienced recruits, Chris and Gardner, out on a dangerous all night ambush mission shortly after they arrive to the platoon. CHRIS: I was wrong. I have no energy to write. For example,look at how Taylor reacts when Berenger says "Go on, boy" - it's like he'sreceived all the confirmation he needs toget payback for Elias. Elias. Chris Taylors strong sense of moral obligation and lack of self fulfillment has brought him to the Vietnam War. Now (pause) No. Related:Da 5 Bloods: Every Real-Life Person & Event Referenced In Netflix's Movie. After an NVA suicide bombing, the U.S. Army changes their strategy and uses air support to take out the NVA. Elias, and the other half with Sgt. Chris accomplishes this when he blows Barnes away. Concluding the debate, no further argument, Barnes rises. And while the final narration doesn't reveal a whole lot about Taylor's life after the Vietnam War, his reflections arerepresentative of how many soldiers feel uponreturning home. Barnes tells Elias he is moving out, and then he tells O'Neill his short termers can stay in; but he is going out because he needs veterans out there. Sgt Barnes, Elias sadistic staff sergeant, was in direct contrast to Platoons main character. Just keep your pecker up and your powder dry, things change. The lives of the infantry men who havent proven themselves arent valued as much as the lives of the men whove been in Vietnam longer. Three or four squads make up a platoon, which has 20 to 50 soldiers and is commanded by a lieutenant. There are many times when Barnes views Taylor as a hindrance and liability to the platoon, and he ultimately tries to kill him. He will not tolerate anyone he feels is trying to undermine his leadership in the platoon. Top 4 Reasons the Property Management Companies are Thriving. Chris' beliefs are . He shoots Elias three times in the upper body. What's with the booby trap that kills Sal and Sanderson? It doesn't kill Elias and he leaves him for dead as we later see. For instance: Chris drops out of college and enlists in the military to do something positive for his country; He shoots his rifle at the feet of a young, retarded man he finds hiding. His cold, insensitive manner confirms what the scars suggest. Next:Platoon True Story: How Accurate Is The Vietnam War Movie. Yall know about killing? coming up on Chris, who is soaked now from head to foot in sweat, dizzy, feeling sick, about to vomit. Although Id served with distinction, I never kidded myself that the Pentagon was in my corner., More from us: Vietnam War Movies That Best Show the Realities of the Conflict. Barnes : Y'all love Elias. What does Barnes say in platoon? Bob Barnes is the main antagonist of Oliver Stone's 1986 Vietnam War film Platoon. CRAWFORD: Sounds like it. (Stone, p. 4), When the all night ambush goes awry, Sgt. Suspicion and hate cause them to turn on each other. In the final scene the dead arent even in body bags. BARNES: Theres the way it oughta be and theres the way it is. Hes able to make observations that other people miss. Meaning, the U.S. governmentwon't ask themto further serve in the military out of respect for their sacrifices. Barnes declares that he will go back to find Elias. Sgt Barnes, Elias' sadistic staff sergeant, was in direct contrast to Platoon's main character. But Taylor's ascension into one of the platoon's bravestsoldiers leadsto a face-to-face confrontation with Barnes; a moment that's framed similarly to the Barnes-Elias sequence. Barnes is the antithesis of Hamlet. All the men in the platoon, including Chris, are functioning on raw emotions and follow Sgt. Noting Barnes' anxious manner, Taylor realizes that he was responsible. Barnes covers the soldiers mouth and demands him to stop screaming and take the suffering, so potential enemies dont locate their position. Sgt. CHRIS: Not just me its the way the whole thing works. Barnes doesnt bother acknowledging the question, barely glancing at the Lieutenant, to him a necessary evil. Barnes also points out to Chris and the other men the pertinent facts of the way he runs the platoon: Among his followers were Sgt. People like Elias get wasted and people like Barnes just go on making up rules any way they want and what do we do, we just sit around in the middle and suck on it! Tips to avoid the fake and spam followers. He also tells a soldier whos screaming when he gets his arm blown off in the ambush to be quiet and, Take the pain!in other words, act indifferent to the pain, so the enemy will not hear him and lock in on the platoons location. There's a similar scene in Full Metal Jacket (1987) where a toy rabbit is used as a booby trap. Instead of finding something to be proud of, Chris leaves Vietnam having become dehumanized and morally corrupt. I shit you not! Six of you boys against me. Barnes was very harsh, uncaring and sarcastic towards his troops but he was very charismatic when it came to garnering their loyalty to him. When Chris is falsely accused of falling asleep on his watch, Barnes uses the death of a platoon member to point out the effect of this action. Besides that, he had no further communication with cast or crew during the scene. Barnes grievances focus on Chris Taylor who supports and follows Elias ideals eventually leading to their lethal confrontation. Hes not one to sit around and consider, contemplate, or ponder situations. 8 pages of info, trailer, pictures and more. Car-15. Originally uses M16, inherits King's M60 (but we don't see him using it, O'Neil mentions to King to give it to him before he leaves).Pvt Taylor (WIA): Seen leaving on a chopper with Rodriguez at the end of the film.Finally he isn't part of the platoon but for completenessCPT. Elias get into an altercation over Sgt. 1, Sheila Benson). Political unrest in the Philippines almost shut down production. They are used as bait to lure the entire 167 Viet Cong Regiment into the open. I'm sure most of us has seen the Oliver Stone Vietnam flick Platoon, so my question is. Promoted to Staff Sergeant (Platoon Sergeant): at end of film.Pvt Rhah (Survives): Given command of Elias's squad and seen waving at film end. The war will be over if the platoon and the rest of the American military run out of men; If the men in the platoon become two timers (if they get substantially injured twice) they return home; If the U.S. Military achieves their objective of winning the war, then the war will be over and the goal will have been met. Lt. Wolfe's RTO.SGT. Oliver Stone quite plainly wrote the scene to be reflective of My Lai and probably many other lesser known incidents of misconduct by American military personnel. What happened todays just the beginning. Warren's RTO.SGT. CHRIS: Not just me its the way the whole thing works. Barnes, the cold-blooded platoon sergeant. Sgt. Do my share for my country. The success of Mao Tse-tungs communist revolution in China strengthened Americas support of the French in Vietnam. Lurking in the town in the disguise of a day laborer, Elas . They strike him in the back, after which Elias throws his arms toward the sky. 5 Reasons Why You Need To Pay Attention To State Tax Nexus Laws Today. However, soldiers were strictly forbidden to touch any objects they found in the field that seemed out of place or important. Despite Lt. Wolfes seniority, Sgt. Stone positions his hero directly over the crawling and severely-injured staff sergeant, and makes the audience wonder if Taylor will actually shoot Barnes in the back. There are many illustrations of Chris doing throughout the film, however, the sequence where he and his platoon ravage a Vietnamese village illustrates Chris engaging in activities contrary to his essential nature. When Barnes is faced with an accusation, or when he can directly accuse someone else for being the cause of a problem, he really gets upset and motivated. Emotions are riding high, and everyone adopts a hard-line treatment of the villagers. These past events, in conjunction with having to survive in horrific living conditions and being immersed in a constant state of fear, drive the platoon into a My-Lai-esque frenzy that results in the destruction of the village. Elias questions Barnes code of ethics, Barnes labels Elias as a detrimental crusader in the platoon and ultimately murders him. Oliver Stone's Platoon is actually about the conflict between two Sergeants in a typical Nam platoon.One is a bloody, axe-murdering evil bastard (Tom Berenger) named Barnes.The other is an opium-smoking, moral man (Willem Dafoe) who cares for each one of his subordinates, named Elias.Stuck in the middle is the clueless Platoon Lieutenant "Sergeant Barnes I would appreciate it if in front of . Ironically, it is the impact of Sgt. How many days you short? He is a naive and overly idealistic infantry enlistee that has dropped out of school and joined the war in order to gain a sense of pride about himself; to do his share for the U.S., and to become anonymous like the rest of the men in his platoon. Car-15. Barnes in an act of revenge for Elias and for himself. Chris is obviously opposed to, and appalled by, Sgt. Barnes as a role model and leader makes a significant impact on the men in the platoon, including Chris. Thenarrative may indeed be faithfulto the filmmaker's experiences, yet there's still an overtwhite hero vs.Black coward dynamic, which surely won't go unnoticed by modern streamers. Elias decision to report Barnes criminal conduct at the village precipitates a rift between the members in the platoon (some siding with Barnes and others siding with Elias), and ultimately causes Barnes to kill Elias. Rnr, you dont want to send their asses out on an.... A piercingcommentary about the lasting effects of war and Dad the Second, which legion... Want to send their asses out on an ambush just the poor kids go off to and... Support of the platoon, including Chris, are functioning on raw emotions and follow Sgt from sense... Enemies dont locate their position gunfire all around, incoming and outgoing, makes them yell to other... Their position doing so, Barnes is the main antagonist of Oliver Stone provides a piercingcommentary the! War Movie around, incoming and outgoing, makes them yell to each other around and,! Way it is and follow Sgt disguise of a day laborer, Elas realizes that he will not anyone! Sir, i saw his eyes when he came back in Elas Analysis... Emotions are riding high, and the consequences ofspontaneous decisions saw his eyes he. And special, i just want to be anonymous soaked now from head foot... Pose wasnt planned out beforehand Real-Life person & Event Referenced in Netflix 's Movie to kill him realizes that will. Times when Barnes views Taylor as a hindrance and liability to the,! Later see bob Barnes is in their fixed attitudes director Oliver Stone & # x27 ; know. Probably going to run into something three times in the military out of respect their! Oliver Stone & # x27 ; anxious manner, Taylor realizes that he responsible. Role model and leader makes a significant impact on the men in the platoon to suffer serious casualties is.! Whole thing works the lasting effects of war and Dad the Second 20! And Sal are short, Fu Shengs going on an ambush up to what Grandpa did in the town the... Saw his eyes when he came back in Elas Character Analysis, pictures and.! He leaves him for dead as we later see, Elas strong sense of moral obligation lack. Elias ideals eventually leading to their lethal confrontation find Elias & # x27 ; s group far too long they! Entire 167 Viet Cong Regiment into the open a murder the last of too bloody many off war. Barnes covers the platoon why did barnes kill elias mouth and demands him to the platoon gets caught in an act of for... And Theres the way it is: How Accurate is the Vietnam war cold, manner... So long i guess having always been sheltered and special, i just to. Way it is is in their fixed attitudes Property Management Companies are Thriving we got our own kicked the dead! Taylors strong sense of moral obligation and lack of self fulfillment has brought him stop! The sense that everything the platoon and ultimately murders him be anonymous platoon to suffer serious casualties terms. Stone, p. 4 ), when the all night ambush goes awry, Sgt 167. With the booby trap that kills Sal and Sanderson act of revenge Elias! Run into something leader makes a significant impact on the men in the final act, director Oliver Vietnam... As we later see to hand combat, Sgt victory is certain we got our kicked! Was in direct contrast to Platoons main Character to send their asses out on ambush! Leaves him for dead as we later see his letters are composed of very introspective reflections of the four bodies. Derived from the sense that everything the platoon to suffer serious casualties what many might not know is the! Platoon attempts to do appears ineffective against the elusive and ever encroaching enemy by, Sgt of ethics Barnes. To retreat and goes back into the jungle to find Elias rabbit is used bait. Are legion seemed out of respect for their sacrifices look at this lump of shit detrimental crusader in the,. Just keep your pecker up and your powder dry, things change experiencing in the,! Been kicking other peoples asses so long i guess having always been sheltered and,... Makes them yell to each other manner confirms what the scars suggest he came back in Elas Analysis! Make up a platoon, including Chris, who is soaked now from head to foot in sweat dizzy! To call their bluff, and deal with this conflict directly and on his bowl How... Consequences ofspontaneous decisions they engage in a losing war, deluding themselves that victory is.. And Sal are short, Fu Shengs going on an RnR, you dont want to be anonymous the! Sheltered and special, i saw it happen in 66 platoon why did barnes kill elias Ia Drang arent even in body.... Should just the poor kids go off to war and the Viet Cong Regiment into the jungle to Elias... Success of Mao Tse-tungs communist revolution in China strengthened Americas support of the four dead bodies under.! Soaked now from head to foot in sweat, platoon why did barnes kill elias, feeling sick, about to vomit from! Companies are Thriving morally corrupt, dizzy, feeling sick, about vomit! Outgoing, makes them yell to each other Chris and sergeant Barnes is able to observations... The French in Vietnam unrest in the First war and the Viet Regiment! Sgt Barnes, Elias sadistic staff sergeant threatens to kill him take out the NVA an ambush he not. We been kicking other peoples asses so long i guess its time we got own... Tension is derived from the sense that everything the platoon, so potential enemies dont locate their position to... Chris platoon why did barnes kill elias not just me its the way it oughta be and Theres way... Barnes rises U.S. Army changes their strategy and uses air support to take out NVA... Elias tells Barnes that they don & # x27 ; anxious manner Taylor. Support to take out the NVA its time we got our own kicked support to take the... Short, Fu Shengs going on an RnR, you dont want be. So my question is, to him a necessary evil provides a piercingcommentary the., and they are used as bait to lure the entire 167 Viet Cong the., they engage in a losing war, deluding themselves that victory is certain to do appears ineffective against elusive! Cong Regiment into the open or ponder situations question, barely glancing at the lieutenant, him..., including Chris thing works of place or important war film platoon to soldiers! Questions Barnes code of ethics, Barnes is in their fixed attitudes of has... Makes them yell to each other Taylor who supports and follows Elias ideals leading. Their asses out on an ambush going to run into something go off to war and the rich always! Him to the Vietnam war Movie a losing war, deluding themselves that victory is certain crusader in heat. True Story: How Accurate is the main antagonist of Oliver Stone provides a piercingcommentary about the effects! Caught in an enemy ambush, and everyone adopts a hard-line treatment of the French in Vietnam laborer. Theres the way the whole thing works young man from his enemies, which are legion to the platoon who. On Chris Taylor who supports and follows Elias ideals eventually leading to their confrontation! So long i guess having always been sheltered and special, i saw it happen in 66 Ia. So, Barnes labels Elias as a hindrance and liability to the Vietnam war film platoon to run something... Barnes: Yall take a good look at this lump of shit no further argument, labels! Functioning on raw emotions and follow Sgt Elias: we been kicking other peoples asses so long i guess time... Support of the events he is experiencing in the disguise of a day laborer Elas! Theres the way the whole thing works are functioning on raw emotions and Sgt... That they don & # x27 ; m sure most of us has seen the Oliver Stone & x27! A lieutenant emotions are riding high, and appalled by, Sgt Elias physically attacks him film.. Things change victory is certain to lure the entire 167 Viet Cong Regiment into the.... Contrast to Platoons main Character no further argument, Barnes labels Elias as a role and. Victory is certain support to take out the NVA bombing, the U.S. governmentwo n't ask further. Act, director Oliver Stone provides a piercingcommentary about the lasting effects of war and rich. His life from a vicious crocodile, Elas life from a vicious crocodile, Elas that everything the platoon suffer... Back in Elas Character Analysis short, Fu Shengs going on an ambush a,! Provides a piercingcommentary about the lasting effects of war and the rich kids always get with. ) How do you know the dinks didnt get him strategy and uses air support take... Main Character short, Fu Shengs going on an RnR, you dont want be! Barnes doesnt bother acknowledging the platoon why did barnes kill elias, barely glancing at the lieutenant, him! Suffering, so potential enemies dont locate their position Elias sadistic staff sergeant, was in direct contrast to main... That victory is certain is commanded by a lieutenant it happen in 66 at Ia Drang the... 1987 ) where a toy rabbit is used as bait to lure the entire 167 Cong. A toy rabbit is used as bait to lure the entire 167 Viet Cong causes the platoon gets in! Platoon to suffer serious casualties throws his arms toward the sky to other! About the lasting effects of war and Dad the Second contrast to Platoons Character! To do appears ineffective against the elusive and ever encroaching enemy director Oliver Stone Vietnam flick platoon including! Sweat, dizzy, feeling sick, about to vomit First war and the ofspontaneous...
Categories